Search
Bright updated split-level living room with oak floors, a short stair to the dining area and a picture window overlooking a late-autumn New Jersey garden.

Closter Home Prices, From Original Split-Level to New Foundation

On October 26, a three-bedroom colonial at 7 Asmus Road in Closter sold for $993,000. Five days earlier, a four-bedroom contemporary farther down the same road, at 62 Asmus Road, came on the market at $1,799,000. Its listing on the New Jersey Multiple Listing Service says the house was "completely rebuilt on a combination of new and existing foundation," and it backs onto the Nature Center trails. That is one street, one week and one more bedroom, with roughly $800,000 between the two prices.

Recent Closter sales follow this pattern. A buyer looking at houses for sale in Closter this winter is choosing a tier, and the tiers depend more on how much of the house is new than on bedroom count. NJMLS tracks this directly. Its year-built field has two separate labels, "New Const-Existing Fdn" and "New Const-New Fdn," and in Closter's current prices the foundation is where the biggest jumps happen.

Original Split-Levels Sell Close to the County Median

Closter's entry tier is the original split-level and the modest colonial, usually with three bedrooms and one and a half baths. These sales from late summer through early November fall in a narrow band:

Address Style Beds / Baths Sold Price Sold Date
181 Crescent Street Split Level 3 / 1.5 $840,000 Aug 31, 2026
11 Lockwood Lane Split Level 3 / 1.5 $845,000 Oct 13, 2026
14 Greenway Court Split Level 3 / 1.5 $865,000 Sep 25, 2026
27 West Street Colonial 3 / 2.5 $900,000 Nov 3, 2026
103 Primrose Lane Split Level 3 / 1.5 $925,000 Sep 11, 2026
9 Smith Street Split Level 4 / 2 $940,000 Aug 20, 2026
7 Asmus Road Colonial 3 / 1.5 $993,000 Oct 26, 2026
310 Ruckman Road Split Level 3 / 2.5 $1,070,000 Aug 21, 2026

Six of these eight sales closed between $840,000 and $940,000. Across Bergen County, the median sale price for single-family homes in October 2026 was $880,000, according to the NJ REALTORS Local Market Update for Bergen County. Closter's original split-level is therefore roughly a county-median house. The 9 Smith Street sale shows how little a fourth bedroom moves the price in this tier: it closed at $940,000, $15,000 above the three-bedroom on Primrose Lane.

One-Level Houses Sell Above Larger Split-Levels

The next tier is single-floor and bi-level houses. On September 1, a three-bedroom ranch at 436 Ruckman Road sold for $1,250,000. A week later, on September 8, a three-bedroom ranch at 22 Center Street sold for $1,210,000. On October 15, a five-bedroom bi-level at 14 Chestnut Avenue closed at the same $1,250,000.

Compare those prices with the 9 Smith Street split-level. A three-bedroom ranch sold for about $270,000 more than a four-bedroom split-level that closed within a few weeks of it. The five-bedroom bi-level on Chestnut Avenue sold for no more than the three-bedroom ranch on Ruckman Road. In this tier the style of the house matters more to price than the number of bedrooms, and the next tier makes the same point more strongly.

The Biggest Jump Comes With the Rebuild

Above roughly $1.25 million, recent sales thin out until about $1.72 million. Then a cluster of larger, finished colonials and rebuilt houses appears:

  • 42 Harvey Street: a five-bedroom colonial with four full and two half baths. It sold for $1,755,000 on September 14.
  • 181 West Street: a five-bedroom colonial with four and a half baths. It sold for $1,720,000 on November 12, the most recent closing in this tier.
  • 62 Asmus Road: listed in October at $1,799,000 and described as rebuilt on a mix of new and existing foundation.
  • 514 High Street: a five-bedroom colonial listed at $1,750,000. Its NJMLS listing says the house was "totally rebuilt on an expanded foundation." It first came on the market on May 20.
  • 70 Pine Street: a brick colonial built in the 2000s, with five bedrooms and over 5,000 square feet on a 12,500-square-foot lot. It came back on the market October 21 at $1,799,888.

From the 14 Greenway Court split-level at $865,000 to the 181 West Street colonial at $1,720,000, the difference is about $855,000. In Closter, that gap is what a buyer pays to skip renovation and own a house that is already finished. Bedrooms explain only part of it. The four-bedroom 62 Asmus Road is asking about $550,000 more than the five-bedroom bi-level on Chestnut Avenue sold for.

This tier gives a buyer a practical choice. One option is to buy at the bottom tier, around $850,000 to $950,000, and take on the work, the schedule and the approvals themselves. The other is to buy in the $1.7 million range after someone else has done it. Which one fits depends on time, appetite for a project and how a buyer's financing is structured. The market is pricing the finished house at close to double the original.

A New Foundation Is a Separate Tier

Brand-new construction from the ground up sits another step higher. In October, 26 Collins Avenue was listed at $2,700,000 as "brand new construction / new foundation," with six bedrooms and six full baths plus a half bath. Its MLS year-built field carries only the "New Const-New Fdn" label.

That asking price is about $900,000 above the rebuilt houses on High Street and Asmus Road. The step from an existing foundation to a new one is about as large as the step from an original split-level to a rebuild. This pattern makes the year-built field one of the most useful filters on a Closter search. The labels "New Const-Existing Fdn," "New Const-New Fdn" and a decade like "2020's" mark three different price points, even when the photos look alike. 62 Asmus Road carries both construction labels because it was built on a mix of new and old foundation.

Taxes Rise With Each Tier

A buyer's costs keep rising after closing. The 14 Greenway Court split-level showed annual property taxes of $13,068 on its listing. The 70 Pine Street colonial, a 2000s-built house in the $1.8 million range, shows $25,210. Moving up from the split-level tier to the finished-colonial tier roughly doubles the purchase price and roughly doubles the annual tax line too, so a monthly payment estimate should use the tax figure for the tier being considered. These figures come from individual listings and are general information, not tax or financial advice. Confirm the numbers for a specific property with your own tax professional or lender.

How Much Room Buyers Have This Winter

The Bergen County numbers for October 2026 show a market that has eased slightly from a year earlier while prices kept rising. The NJ REALTORS October 2026 update for Bergen County shows:

  • 405 single-family closings in October 2026, against 446 in October 2025, a 9.2% drop
  • a median sale price up 9.3%, to $880,000
  • average days on market up from 35 to 39
  • sellers receiving 102.0% of list price, down from 102.6%
  • inventory of 1,166 homes, up 15.7%
  • 2.8 months of supply, up from 2.3

In a Closter context, the county's typical home still sells above asking, but with a little more time and a little more choice than last fall. The split-level tier is the one most exposed to county-wide competition, because its prices sit right at the county median. In the upper tiers, the asking prices are spread across fewer houses. For example, 514 High Street has been listed since May, and 62 Asmus Road and 70 Pine Street both came on the market in the same October week. With finished houses sitting near each other in price, a buyer in that range can compare them directly. A buyer in the split-level range is more likely competing with other buyers for one house.

For the broader monthly picture, see our New Jersey market reports and the Closter neighborhood page.

Questions Buyers Ask About Closter's Tiers

How can I tell on a listing whether a house was rebuilt or newly built? Check the year-built field before the photos. Closter listings in the local MLS use "New Const-Existing Fdn" for houses rebuilt on an original foundation and "New Const-New Fdn" for ground-up construction. Some houses, like 62 Asmus Road, carry both labels. The listing remarks usually add detail, such as "totally rebuilt on an expanded foundation" at 514 High Street.

Are new single-family houses still being started in Closter? Applications are still coming in. In August 2026, an applicant at 35 Harvard Street asked the Planning Board for a major soil-movement permit to build a new single-family house.

Is any other kind of housing being added in town? Village School Commons at 511 Durie Avenue is turning the former Village School into 35 income-restricted rental homes. The Press Group reported that ground was broken on January 21, 2026, with completion projected by 2027. The borough announced on October 8 that the application process for the homes was open.

If you are deciding between an original Closter split-level you would renovate and a house someone has already rebuilt, CrystalsCity can walk through the Closter comparable sales with you and help you weigh the gap before you make an offer. Schedule a consultation, or if you own one of these houses and are thinking about selling, request a free home valuation to see which tier your house falls in.

Let’s Work Together

Crystal Burns is committed to understanding your goals and delivering results that exceed your expectations. Let’s work together to achieve your goals.

Follow Me on Instagram