"When you're in a small town like Tenafly, it could easily become just like the hundreds of other suburban towns with downtowns consisting of three or four blocks of chain stores with little personality."
Isaac Ben-Avraham, who owns Café Angelique in the old train station at 1 Piermont Road, said that to The Tenafly Echo last December, when word got out that Starbucks wanted a location a couple of blocks from his café. Ten months later, Starbucks is still not open. The Serafina space on Highwood Avenue isn't either. The chain that actually arrives first this fall is a bagel shop that wasn't even part of the conversation a year ago.
That order isn't random. The three projects are moving at three very different speeds, and each one is going about as fast as its building allows.
The Fast One: A Bagel Counter in a Washington Street Storefront
PopUp Bagels has set its grand opening for Friday, October 9, at 6-8 Washington Street. The celebration runs from 8 to 11 a.m. with a DJ, merch giveaways, and a limited carrot cake schmear, available while supplies last. The schmear comes from chef Josh Capon, who calls Tenafly his hometown. He recently opened Capon's Burgers in Paramus and Capon's Chophouse in Hackensack.
The timeline has been short. The Echo reported in late May that Infinitea had closed for good and PopUp Bagels signage had gone up in its place on Washington Street. A few days after the signs first appeared, people wearing black PopUp Bagels shirts were spotted at the Night Market. The Chamber's Night Market ran May 16 along Washington Street, West Railroad Avenue, and Tenafly Road. So the whole process, from signage to grand opening, took about five months.
PopUp Bagels started in Westport, Connecticut. NJBIZ reports the brand has opened 50 locations nationwide and plans at least two dozen in New Jersey, with Tenafly the second of them. A model built on that pace depends on moving into an existing retail space and opening quickly, and that's what happened on Washington Street.
The Slow One: Serafina on Highwood Avenue
Serafina has been coming for much longer. Boozy Burbs reported in October 2024 that the New York Italian restaurant was headed to Tenafly. It will be the brand's first New Jersey location. By May 2026, The Echo wrote that Serafina's yellow-and-blue wallpaper had been up in a doorway on Highwood Avenue for more than a year and the restaurant was "still a work in progress." The paper also noted that painters, construction workers, and food trucks had started showing up.
The most recent public step came on July 13, 2026. That day, the Mayor and Council approved outdoor seating applications for several downtown businesses, including Serafina at 25 Highwood Avenue, and told the Borough Clerk to issue the permits. An outdoor seating permit isn't an opening date, and none has been announced. As of this writing, Serafina's own Tenafly page still says "Coming Soon."
A full-service restaurant takes more work than a bagel counter. It needs a dining room, a commercial kitchen, and a bar program. That's why the same downtown can produce a five-month opening and a two-year one.
The Slowest One: A Drive-Through at County Road and Highwood
The Starbucks proposal is a different kind of project altogether. The applicant, Shairco New Jersey LLC, filed application PB#1-25-01 for 71 County Road, which covers Block 1006, Lots 1, 2 and 3. It asks for preliminary and final site plan approval, variances, and soil-moving approval for a Starbucks with a drive-through and parking. The site sits at the corner of County Road and Highwood Avenue.
So far, the public record shows a hearing that keeps getting carried forward:
| Date | What the borough record shows |
|---|---|
| October 8, 2025 | Planning Board hears PB#1-25-01 and continues it to December 10 |
| November 24, 2025 | Council notes the application is before the Planning Board |
| January 15, 2026 | Environmental Commission minutes say the applicant wanted design changes and expected to return February 25 |
| February 25, 2026 | Revisions responding to the October meeting not yet complete; carried to April 22 |
| April 22 and May 27, 2026 | Agendas list 71 County Road as a continued public hearing |
| July 13, 2026 | Council minutes name Starbucks and the Clinton Inn as two main projects in a discussion of traffic studies |
The borough records reviewed for this post don't include a final Planning Board decision, and there's no announced opening. In the July discussion, the engineer said he would talk with Planning and Zoning about traffic studies. A project that changes how cars enter and leave a busy corner gets that kind of review. A storefront swap on Washington Street doesn't. Anyone who wants to follow the case can watch the Tenafly Agenda Center for the next Planning Board agenda that lists 71 County Road.
What Hasn't Moved
The places these chains get compared to are all still open and still at the same addresses.
Café Angelique is still at 1 Piermont Road. It was on the same July 13 outdoor seating resolution as Serafina, and its online ordering still takes scheduled orders. The Echo's December profile described the building's high ceilings, baby blue walls, and cathedral-shaped windows. It noted three small tables up front and a larger dining room in back, and that the café doesn't advertise its Wi-Fi. "A café should be a place where you observe and interact, instead of disappearing into devices," Ben-Avraham said. Asked about Starbucks, he said: "I'm not afraid of new competition, just like how I'm not afraid of the old competition."
Mel's Butcher Box is at 10 West Railroad Avenue. Its posted hours are Monday through Saturday, 11 a.m. to 8 p.m., and Sunday from noon to 6 p.m., with Sundays running until 8 p.m. during football season. The Echo's May piece pointed to it as Railroad Avenue's community-driven alternative to fast food.
Celebrity Bagels is the local business that will feel PopUp's arrival most directly. The Echo article asked outright what would happen to it once PopUp opened, and mentioned a recent rebrand with a new red logo featuring flames. The two students quoted had different takes. One missed the shop's traditional options. The other said, "Whichever bagel is better is the one I will choose." Starting October 9, Tenafly will have two bagel shops downtown, each with its own following.
An October That Mixes Old and New
The rest of the month runs on calendars that have nothing to do with any of this. The Chamber scheduled its free Fall Fest for October 4 at Huyler Park, at Piermont Avenue and West Railroad Avenue, with a costume contest at 12:45 p.m. After that, the Tenafly Nature Center carries most of October:
- Apple Cider Making on October 10, 11, 18 and 24, with several sessions on the listed days
- October's Seasonal Scavenger Hunt on October 10 and Forest Defenders on October 11
- Campfire & Cocktails, the center's fall fundraiser for guests 21 and older, moved by weather from September 26 to Saturday, October 17, from 6 to 9 p.m.
- Nature Story Time on October 17 and Heal and Hike on October 18
- The Haunted Forest on Sunday, October 25, at 313 Hudson Avenue, a family-friendly guided tour about nocturnal wildlife with time slots from 1 to 5 p.m.
A Saturday that uses both calendars could start with coffee at Café Angelique, then a cider session at the Nature Center, then dinner from Mel's. On October 10, the first of those Saturdays, PopUp Bagels will be one day into its run at 6-8 Washington Street.
Downtown changes affect more than where you get breakfast. If you own near Washington Street, Highwood Avenue or County Road and want to know how Tenafly's next few openings might shape buyer interest on your block, Crystal Burns can walk you through it over a consultation or a free home valuation.